
Solid Conservatory Roof or Glass? Choosing for a Sheffield Home
Tiles, glass and polycarbonate each cure a different complaint. Below, the trade-offs, plus a look at how they sit against stone villas, brick terraces and everything in between.
Most people who start looking at a new roof assume the answer is solid. It is the roof everyone talks about, and the photos look like a proper room. Often it is the right call. But a solid roof is also the dearest, the heaviest and the one that brings building control into it, so it pays to know what the other two do well before you decide.
Start with the question you are trying to answer. Is the room unbearable in July? Freezing in February? Too noisy to sit in when it rains? Or does the roof just look tired and leak at one corner? Each of those points somewhere slightly different.
The three roofs side by side
General comparisons, not promises. A good glass roof can beat a poorly fitted solid one, so the firm matters as much as the material.
| What you notice | Tiled solid roof | Glass | Polycarbonate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Daylight | Dimmer overhead; a lantern or rooflights help | Brightest of the lot | Bright at first, milkier with age |
| Summer heat | The coolest by a distance | Better than plastic, still warm on sunny days | Gets hot quickly in direct sun |
| Winter warmth | Insulated like a house roof | Better than plastic, colder than a solid roof | Loses heat fast |
| Rain noise | Quiet | Some drumming | Loud in a heavy shower |
| Weight on the frame | Heavy: frame, door supports and base need checking | Heavier than plastic, much lighter than tiles | Light |
| Building regs | Usually needs approval | Rarely, if it stays a glazed conservatory | Rarely, if it stays a glazed conservatory |
| Medium roof, guide price | around £8k to £12k | around £3.5k to £5k | around £2.5k to £4k |
Prices are national guides for a medium conservatory, not quotes. See the cost page for every size.
Tiled solid roof
A tiled roof, often sold as a warm roof, replaces glazing with an insulated frame, light tiles or slates outside and skimmed plasterboard overhead. Inside, the greenhouse feeling fades and the room behaves like an extension. That change is what people are paying for.
Best for: rooms that overheat in summer, rooms you want to use all year, and anyone who is tired of rain hammering overhead. Spotlights in the ceiling make it feel finished.
The trade: daylight goes first. What was the sunniest spot downstairs can turn noticeably gloomier, and that is the usual reason people set a lantern or a pair of rooflights into the tiles. Price is the other trade, and approval is a third: an insulated roof ends the room's status as an exempt conservatory, so building control has to sign it off.
Will your frame cope with the weight?
Put this to every firm that visits. A tiled build-up outweighs plastic sheeting many times over, and the original frame was sized for sheeting. Inspectors look for evidence that window frames, posts, any beam spanning the patio doors and the footings below can all bear it.
You may find one firm says the frame is fine and another wants to add posts or a ring beam (a structural frame that sits on top of the windows and takes the roof's weight). Ask each of them to explain why. A firm that has looked at the base and the frame properly will be able to tell you.
Glass
Modern double-glazed roof units look sharper than tired plastic and hold on to the daylight that drew you to a conservatory originally. Coated units blunt the worst of the summer sun and keep in more warmth than plastic, though no glazed roof rivals a properly insulated one.
Glass is heavier than plastic, so the frame still needs to be sound, but a like-for-like glazed roof normally stays a conservatory in the eyes of the regulations. If the walls and doors are in good order and your main gripe is the roof itself, it can be a sensible middle path.
Polycarbonate
New polycarbonate sheets in the frame you already have is the lowest outlay and the quickest job. It is fair to say it fixes a leak or a cloudy roof rather than changing how the room feels.
Expect the same character as before: bright, noisy in rain, warm in sun and cool in winter. Polycarbonate also tends to discolour and go brittle over the years, so this is often the choice when you plan to move before long or want the room usable on a tight budget.
How long each one lasts
In general terms, a well-built tiled roof is made to last in the way a house roof does, glass units last well if the seals are good, and polycarbonate is the shortest-lived. Ask each firm what guarantee they give and what it covers.
Which roof suits which Sheffield house?
Sheffield's streets swing between stone, brick and render, and a new conservatory roof is seen against the house every day. Roughly how that shakes out:
- Sandstone villas in places like Ranmoor and Endcliffe: many of these went up between 1860 and 1914 with Welsh slate roofs. A grey slate-look tile usually sits better than a terracotta one, and if the house is in a conservation area it is worth asking the council before changing the look.
- Red-brick terraces and semis: the suburbs are full of them. A solid roof with a darker tile tends to blend in, and a lean-to style often fits the narrow plots.
- Arts and Crafts houses with render and clay tiles: a warm clay-toned tile, or simply glass, usually sits more comfortably beside these than grey slate.
- Homes on steep, open slopes: wherever the conservatory faces open hillside, mention the exposure at the survey and ask how the roof is fixed and drained.
If your home is listed, or sits in one of Sheffield's conservation areas such as Nether Edge, Broomhill or Dore, read the building regs and planning page before choosing.
Torn between tiles and glass?
Someone stood in your conservatory, looking at its frame and your house, can settle it far faster than any table.
Once it lands, we hunt out one independent business fitting conservatory roofs in your corner of Sheffield and share its name with you. Nothing of yours leaves our hands unless you give the nod, and there is no fee on your side. How it works.
Got it, thank you.
Our next job is tracking down a business that fits conservatory roofs in the streets around the postcode you gave, then telling you its name.
Until you give the nod, your number and email sit with us alone. Once you do, the firm gets in touch to talk the roof through and book a look at it.